Yugioh Card Maker Forum

Full Version: |Darth Browarod vs. Spirit of J-Max| ~Duel of the Ages~
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2
I had mentioned to J-Max on IM that I felt a little sad that nobody had challenged me to a 1vs1 (except for one special case, but that doesn't count as it's still in the works), and he was gracious enough to challenge me to a contest. We both decided to use cards made in the last week, so you may have already seen one or both of them.

Anyway, here are the entries:

~||~

[Image: 48078gn4.jpg]
Image found on a Hentai Site
This card cannot be Normal Summoned or Set. This card can only be Special Summoned from your hand when there are 3 or more DARK monsters removed from play. When this card is Special Summoned successfully, return all monsters removed from play to your Graveyard. During each of your Standby Phases you can remove 1 card in your Graveyard from play to increase the ATK of this card by 1000 until the End Phase. When this card is destroyed, remove this card from play instead.

~||~

[Image: CorruptionKingD34-TH.jpg]
Image spliced from renders at planetrenders.net
You can Special Summon this card from your hand when the Battle Positions of 5 or more monsters on the field change by the effect of a card you control. Increase the ATK of this card by 500 for each monster that changed its Battle Position. When this card is destroyed and sent to the Graveyard, change the Battle Positions of all face-up monsters on the field.

~||~

The poll will be open for 48 hours. After that, whichever person has a higher total of votes will be the winner and will receive 3 +reps from the loser. Please, only vote if you're also going to post why you think the one you voted for is better. If you post, please also remember to vote as it's easier to count the total at the end Wink
holy moly! a mod showdown! i call 1st post!
now to evaluate.....

both of your images look awesome
both of your ocg is flawless in my opinion
but i think Spirit of J-Max's card is better, but not by much
Spirit of J-Max wins my vote
second post j-max
Darth Browarod > Spirit of J-Max

Effect is a little more original. (in my opinion)
I think Darth.
Thanks for the votes, everybody, but for those of you who just posted your choice, would you care to let us know why you picked the one you picked, so we can figure out what needs improvement, or what we did well?

Interesting results so far ^_^
Voted for Brow.
Reason-J-Max's card seemed a bit...broken. It's not that hard to get 3 dark monsters removed from play. And 3600 ATK is a bit much for an almost "free" summon.

Also, Brow's card could give birth to a new deck type with Giant Orcs, GAF, IFLL, Zero Grav, and Other position changing cards.
Brow's card seems more oringinal, and J-Max's card seems broken...

Voted for Brow
This is probably the hardest comparison I had to make.

In terms of playability, I would say J-Max's card is better but originality-wise, I would have to vote for Browarod. Browarod's card also seems more balanced despite a lower playability level but I suppose the typing could compensate for that. J-Max's card does indeed seem a little overpowered since it gives a reward in the form of a 2600 ATK beatstick that can get stronger for very little effort in a dedicated deck.

As it stands, I would have to vote for Browarod. Sorry J-Max but this was still not an easy choice for me to make.
Thanks for the comments everyone ^_^

Some good comments already, can't wait to see more Razz


(11-11-2008 02:49 AM)DesCrow Wrote: [ -> ]Also, Brow's card could give birth to a new deck type with Giant Orcs, GAF, IFLL, Zero Grav, and Other position changing cards.
Aha! Someone noticed the secret to my card Razz

Congratz on being the first person to spot that particular mechanic of it Wink
lol Well I am going up against a Legend Smile Thanks for the votes about my card though. I originally had DAD in mind when creating it. It's a Honor Brows.
(11-11-2008 11:20 AM)Spirit of J-Max Wrote: [ -> ]lol Well I am going up against a Legend Smile Thanks for the votes about my card though. I originally had DAD in mind when creating it. It's a Honor Brows.
Indeed. I dare say this should be quite the close match-up Wink
i'm voting for you,Darth.good card!
(11-12-2008 05:57 PM)Mikooo Wrote: [ -> ]i'm voting for you,Darth.good card!
Hey, thanks! Just don't forget to vote in the poll, too Wink
*Checks Poll* This is Incredible! I thought I would be totally Slaughtered by you considering that you taught me a lot Very Happy Thank you so much for your votes people!
(11-12-2008 05:58 PM)Darth Browarod Wrote: [ -> ]
(11-12-2008 05:57 PM)Mikooo Wrote: [ -> ]i'm voting for you,Darth.good card!
Hey, thanks! Just don't forget to vote in the poll, too Wink

I did.you should holo/recolor that card,and it would be much better.
(11-12-2008 06:01 PM)Spirit of J-Max Wrote: [ -> ]*Checks Poll* This is Incredible! I thought I would be totally Slaughtered by you considering that you taught me a lot Very Happy Thank you so much for your votes people!
Lol, you don't give yourself enough credit Wink

(11-12-2008 06:02 PM)Mikooo Wrote: [ -> ]
(11-12-2008 05:58 PM)Darth Browarod Wrote: [ -> ]
(11-12-2008 05:57 PM)Mikooo Wrote: [ -> ]i'm voting for you,Darth.good card!
Hey, thanks! Just don't forget to vote in the poll, too Wink

I did.you should holo/recolor that card,and it would be much better.
Ah, okay. Just checking Wink

And, I am not really a big fan of holos, they don't usually look realistic to me, so that's why I didn't holo this one. I only holo occasionally Razz
I vote Browarods...

Sorry J-Max old buddy, but it was REALLY close.. so close, that I might take a whole month to explain how everything conflicted so perfectly.

I'll just say this.. Browarod got my vote by achieving .0001 of point more than you.
Browarod

Both cards are great in many ways, though
I voted J-Max, simply because I enjoyed the premise of his more. Darth, yours is more of a beatstick. Sorry.
Pages: 1 2
Reference URL's