NEW RULINGs(NOT REAL)! Must make your opponents LP exactly 0.

[X-L]

NEW RULES!


In a duel, in order to win through Battle Damage or Effect Damage, the last card to finish the opponent off must make the opponents Life Points exactly 0. If a player would try to inflict more damage than needed with a monster, all damage is reduced to 0, and you cannot activate the effect of a card/activate a card that would inflict more Effect Damage than needed, or its damage is reduced to 0.


In addition, cards that would make damage towards the opponent or the controller themselves that would make the controller or opponents Life Points tens and single digit nubers between 01-49 or 51-99 are rounded toward the nearest fiftieth, due to the fact that if this ruling were not applied would make the other players Life Points near immpossible to deplete. An exaple is "Castle of Illusions".


And if your opponent has 100 or less Life Points, you can attack with a 100 ATK monster or Card Effect that would cause 100 damage (no more, no less for both) to make the opposing players Life Points 0, even if this would not make the opposing players Life Points exactly 0.



So, saying that these rules were really applied, what would the meta look like, and what kind of new stradegies/Decks would be used?


Discuss.

NOTE: This post has been reported, and is awaiting moderator review

[Bloodline Massacre]

If this is true I might stop playing. That rule is just retarded.

[Icyblue]

Ram "Reaper of the Cards" into your opponents monsters for epic lulz.

[X-L]

(09-02-2009 10:28 PM)davidroof1 Wrote:  If this is true I might stop playing. That rule is just retarded.

This isn't real. I just made it up, so that people can gibe their opinions.

[Bloodline Massacre]

Ah, okay. I wouldn't like it as you can probably tell already.

[Aximil]

(09-02-2009 10:28 PM)Icyblue Wrote:  Ram "Reaper of the Cards" into your opponents monsters for epic lulz.

(09-02-2009 10:22 PM)X-L PRIME!!! Wrote:  In addition, cards that would make damage towards the opponent or the controller themselves that would make the controller or opponents Life Points tens and single digit nubers between 01-49 or 51-99 are rounded toward the nearest fiftieth, due to the fact that if this ruling were not applied would make the other players Life Points near immpossible to deplete. An exaple is "Castle of Illusions".

[Crow™]

*Sees this*
*Head -> Brick Wall*

[Bloodline Massacre]

(09-02-2009 10:33 PM)Syncrow™ Wrote:  *Sees this*
*Head -> Brick Wall*

I lol'd.

[Icyblue]

(09-02-2009 10:32 PM)Aximil Wrote:  

(09-02-2009 10:28 PM)Icyblue Wrote:  Ram "Reaper of the Cards" into your opponents monsters for epic lulz.

(09-02-2009 10:22 PM)X-L PRIME!!! Wrote:  In addition, cards that would make damage towards the opponent or the controller themselves that would make the controller or opponents Life Points tens and single digit nubers between 01-49 or 51-99 are rounded toward the nearest fiftieth, due to the fact that if this ruling were not applied would make the other players Life Points near immpossible to deplete. An exaple is "Castle of Illusions".

Nearest Hundredth.
And maybe, have something to level it out? (So a beatstick deck can stand a chance).

[X-L]

(09-02-2009 10:33 PM)Syncrow™ Wrote:  *Sees this*
*Head -> Brick Wall*

I'm going to put this in my sig anyways.

[Xaioxaio]

Sirroco Pumps, Morphtronic OTK, and Auto-win conditions become meta?

[GenzoTheHarpist]

I would run deckout because this rule would be too damn annoying.

[PikaPerson01]

Run Solemn. Get yourself to anything ending in a 50. Solemn anything. (Because paying a cost isn't inflicting damage.)

On-topic though, once you get to less then 1000 life points, you're pretty much guaranteed not to lose if you're opponent doesn't have anything with 100, 200, 250, or 500 attack.

tl;dr: It's a terrible rule.

[shadowferret]

......
Backs To The Wall would be completely broken in this.

Well, time to use my janky Toon strategy...
Toon Dark Magician Girl + Toon World + Mage Power + Mage Power + Mage Power = Attack for 8000 directly! Whee!

....>_>

[Luxlord]

Victory Dragon would PROBABLY be limited if this rule came into effect.

[Tabris]

Suppose that Konami cooked that one up...

... they f***ed themselves up. Fer real. This time.

The bells ain't tollin' for no good reason.

[Bloodline Massacre]

I dueled myself out of boredom(I'm sick I've nothing better to do) with this rule. I actually won using it. I had Red Gadget and AG Gadjiltron Dragon on the field while the other deck had 2000 lp left. Summoned Cannon Soldier, tributed Red Gadget for effect inflicting 500, then activated AG Explosive for 1500 points of damage. (Yes I'm this bored.)

[burnpsy]

(09-02-2009 11:49 PM)Xaioxaio Wrote:  Morphtronic OTK

This.

Boomboxen tens to swing for nice, round numbers.

[iHop]

(09-02-2009 10:33 PM)Syncrow™ Wrote:  *Sees this*
*Head -> Brick Wall*

(09-03-2009 01:41 AM)PikaPerson01 Wrote:  Run Solemn. Get yourself to anything ending in a 50. Solemn anything. (Because paying a cost isn't inflicting damage.)

On-topic though, once you get to less then 1000 life points, you're pretty much guaranteed not to lose if you're opponent doesn't have anything with 100, 200, 250, or 500 attack.

tl;dr: It's a terrible rule.

Effect Damage

(09-03-2009 03:01 AM)Tabris Wrote:  Suppose that Konami cooked that one up...

... they f***ed themselves up. Fer real. This time.

The bells ain't tollin' for no good reason.

Yes.

Crab helmet Wrote:This topic is stupid

[metalflygon08]

Just wait, Konami's gonna create a card that works similar to this like "If your opponent cannot decrease your Life Points exactly to 0 you take no Damage from card effects or attacks.