Yu-Gi-Oh vs. Magic The Gathering

[FM6]

Yu-Gi-Oh!

[SaTuRnPaLaDiN]

I like Magic a little more, personally.

[Black Rose Phoenix®]

Yu-gi-oh, no offence but that guy/girl is a joke (no offence...but they are...), Magic the gatthering sacks', Christ were did they get the idea Magic the gathering is good...?

[Icyblue]

(09-27-2008 01:36 PM)cardcreator 444 Wrote:  Yu-gi-oh, no offence but that guy/girl is a joke (no offence...but they are...), Magic the gatthering sacks', Christ were did they get the idea Magic the gathering is good...?

Where did you get the idea that MTG was bad?

[SaTuRnPaLaDiN]

Magic is MUCH more strategic than Yu-Gi-Oh. There is so much more you can do in the game, the matches last a lot longer, and everybody doesn't use the same kind of Deck. I don't mock anybody else's opinions, so do not mock mine.

[Icyblue]

(09-27-2008 01:42 PM)SaTuRnPaLaDiN Wrote:  Magic is MUCH more strategic than Yu-Gi-Oh. There is so much more you can do in the game, the matches last a lot longer, and everybody doesn't use the same kind of Deck. I don't mock anybody else's opinions, so do not mock mine.

Added to that, you have much more catch-up time. A match is never decided by a single card..
Even the best cards have drawbacks, regardless of what happens. (Including the Infinite Mana cards etc...)

[Garaa of the Desert]

i saw it he showed it to me not cloud envy the kid he was talking about and is not good at all it was really boring and confusing to i hate it so yeah yugioh rule better than magic.[/i]

[Icyblue]

MTG has most of their rulings on the cards, (Especially the ones that come in the decks have these rulings on them). You can look at earlier cards on how Mana works :/...

Confusing? nah...

[Garaa of the Desert]

who ever likes magic the gathering one question what the f*** are you doing on YCM then.

[Icyblue]

(09-27-2008 09:06 PM)Whizzer_1 Wrote:  who ever likes magic the gathering one question what the f*** are you doing on YCM then.

Didn't think about this one did you?
I do enjoy the YGOTCG immensely lol, but I enjoy the MTG TCG more...
Just because I prefer one does not mean I do not enjoy another...

[Garaa of the Desert]

not just you but others thats just fucken dumb

[Icyblue]

(09-27-2008 09:09 PM)Whizzer_1 Wrote:  not just you but others thats just *censored* dumb

structure better and form a more roundabout opinion please?

[Slash]

Yugioh>Magic

end of thread.

[Garaa of the Desert]

MTG fucken sucks ass if you play you such a major nerd because it is so boring and complicated and dumb how plays it fails in life like cloud said and hes so right

[Icyblue]

(09-27-2008 09:12 PM)Whizzer_1 Wrote:  MTG fucken sucks ass if you play you such a major nerd because it is so boring and complicated and dumb how plays it fails in life like cloud said and hes so right

Additive Inverse Property?
Maybe YGO is too simple?

[Déjà Cru]

Yugimonz + MTG > Yugimonz or MTG

[Garaa of the Desert]

its simple and has a story a line with movies and shows and books and a more funken understandable cards then fucken magic

[Finale Shot]

Whizzer. You're a good friend but shut the he** up.

[Garaa of the Desert]

no im telling the truth to losers how like MTG

[Icyblue]

(09-27-2008 09:24 PM)Whizzer_1 Wrote:  its simple and has a story a line with movies and shows and books and a more funken understandable cards then fucken magic

Boo hoo.
MTG rooted from the biggest impact on young kids of it generation. Dungeons and Dragons.
MTG has been around since about that time, but never really went into proper circulation until the late 80's.
Their system allows even broken cards to be balanced, and it took only 20min for me to learn the game (outside the shortcuts in effects like: Haste and First Strike).

YGO on the other hand is less balanced and hardly fair at the Metagame Level. Also the variety for competitive decks are few and far between.

Stories in the game/show are irrelevant. It is how the game plays out.
Now if you take your cues from an anime to watch (which takes 30min+) than learn how to sit contently for 20min learning MTG. My god do I feel sorry for you...