7 replies to this topic

[Sotos]

Most votes in 5 days win, give reasons for voting...

Sotos

Cursed Reaction

[Daetime Playboy]

Soto, the yellow part of your Tag looks like a box that is randomly there.
Cursed Reactions makes the blend and focals towards the render, even if the blend is a bit too much. Hardly noticeable
Cursed Gets my vote though.

[Sotos]

Well, yeah, the right part was deliberately cut off from the rest, I didn't mean to blend it or anything...Anyway, it's the 1-0 in favor of CR...

[Kakashi Hatake]

Sotos: Although the yellow cut-out on the right of the Tag is kind of an eye sore, I still pretty much like yours. ^^

Cursed Reaction: There really is almost no flow at all. It is just a bunch of C4d's randomly going every which of way. You also badly blended the C4d's together. The left side is the most noticeable account of that. Really, all it look like you did was add in the render, smudge it a bit, add in some C4d's, smudge them a bit, then added a Purple and Orange Gradient Map on Soft Light. :/ Correct me if I'm wrong, but remember that this is all opinion.

My vote goes to Sotos.

[.Rai]

Fair reasoning. To be honest, it is complete C4D spam

1-1

[Sotos]

CR, what do you think of mine? (Not asking you to vote or anything, I just want your opinion...)

[.Rai]

It's really nice. The cutout is a little distracting but the execution's quite nice and the overall feel is really good.

[Night]

Sotos; The Dupe doesn't work at all really, it only gives the piece a horrible second focal, both sides are very monotonous and shows you didn't work too hard on blending the piece. It's pretty boring overall, nothing's amazing about it, basics are lacking.

Cursed; The tag is unnecessarily oversize and c4d's are amateurly placed. Color is bland and boring, overall nothing exciting.

Although Cursed GMV.