Can you solve my riddle?

[Serenity the Candyman]

Which would make them Swindlecants. No that is not the answer. Look at Riddle 7 for more info

[Phantom M.C.]

both are honestants

if a is an honestant and said i'm swindlecat or b is honestant

then b is honestant

[Serenity the Candyman]

+ 1 rep tou you sir for getting it

[Mr Dr Professor Spaz]

the life saving question is... Which door does not lead to my death?

[Phantom M.C.]

ask which door will save me

the guard will point to the door that leads to your death, just choose the other door

or ask which door will lead to my death

the guard will point to the door that will save you

[Serenity the Candyman]

not necessary.
ask which door will save me
The honestant will telll you but the swindlecant wont
and vice versa for the other question
so no

[Phantom M.C.]

oh, i thought there was only 1 swindlecat guard, must've missed that part. i'll try again

so, you can ask each guard 1 question for a total of 2 questions?

[Serenity the Candyman]

no there is only one guard but i was saying that depending on your questions and if the guards were either of the 2 types, you would not get an exact answer.

[Phantom M.C.]

but the riddle said that the guard is a swindlecat

[Serenity the Candyman]

After rereading the riddle....there is two guards.....
my bad for think there was only one

[Phantom M.C.]

so here's the scenario:

2 doors, 1 to death, 1 to life

1 guard is a swindlecat, and the other guard could be either a honestant OR swindlecat

1 question to each of the guards, for a total of 2 questions, or do you have to pick 1 guard and ask 1 question only?

[Squirrel Girl]

Which door is not the door to freedom?

[Sotos]

[color=#1C2837][size=2]"What would you say, if I asked you which is the door to freedom?"[/size][/color]
[color=#1C2837][size=2]If the guard is an Honestant, he would answer correctly, if he was a Swinlecant he would answer correctly, by double-lying, thus negating the lie...[/size][/color][img]http://forum.yugiohcardmaker.net/public/style_emoticons/default/wink.gif[/img]

[Serenity the Candyman]

Sotos has done it +1rep to you
there was a possible of 3 answer:

Indirect question: „Hey you, what would the other guard say, if I asked him where this door leads?“ The answer is always negated.


Tricky question: „Hey you, does an honestant stand at the door to freedom?“ The answer will be YES, if I am asking an honestant who is standing at the door to freedom, or if I am asking a swindlecant standing again at the same door. So I can walk through the door. A similar deduction can be made for negative answer.


Complicated question: „Hey you, what would you say, if I asked you ...?“ An honestant is clear, but a swindlecant should lie. However, he is forced by the question to lie two times and thus speak the truth.

[Phantom M.C.]

i love you <3, but seriously, convince what?

[sirAragorn]

"You are wanted by only poor swindlecats"

[Serenity the Candyman]

close but how does that convince her to pick you?

[Phantom M.C.]

i am the only swindlecat on this island

[Serenity the Candyman]

but shes rich. She wouldnt just want any swindlecant

[Phantom M.C.]

i am the only rich swindlecat on this island

[.Starrk]

Riddle # 8: An Iranian. I win?

[Serenity the Candyman]

nope that is not the answer.

[sirAragorn]

You are wanted only by what I am, a poor swindlecat

[Serenity the Candyman]

so close....but that wording would not convince her.

[sirAragorn]

you are wanted only by poor swindleants, which I am