Depends, if you're giving them out 5 at a time for posting a picture of poop, maybe the problem isn't with me
Anyone can disagree with how many warning points they receive for a given offense, but it doesn't change that they warranted warning points in the first place. Saying that the problem isn't with you is projecting the blame onto the moderation team. It's entirely possible for the moderator to be wrong for how many points they gave and for the user to be still wrong for what they had posted. It's not a case of "This person was really in the wrong, therefore the problem couldn't possibly be with me." As much as I hate "Both sides are wrong" as an excuse, something along those lines needs to be considered.
I'm not a mod anymore. The source of your problems is gone, yet you keep fighting as if I'm still causing the problems. I would prefer it if you were not still using me as your scapegoat.
It's not about smart, it's about personal feelings and agendas
What agenda? Is there one that's even left now? Who is currently acting on this agenda? If they exist, what efforts are they making?