I'll leave the anime of the year type of polling thing to the pros.
It will be 5 polls in 3 parts instead of one from now one so as not to limit it as much. 4 at first and then one at a later date (not specified) combining options voted for the most.
And with that being said, here are my choices for the first half of 2017:
For Winter, Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon. For Spring, although I have not finished it, Hinako Note.